Thumbprint cookies have always been one of my most favorite Christmas cookies. That always seemed bizarre. I was never really into nuts, especially walnuts, and jelly I could take or leave in most instances.
But somehow…when these few ingredients come together, the cookies created take on a magical flavor.
A rich, buttery cookie off-set by the toasted nuts and some homemade jam.
It was high time I perfected a new allergy-friendly version of this recipe! And let me tell you…these are a Christmas treat in this house…otherwise I would eat WAY to many of these delectable morsels!
Thumbprints are also very flexible…if you would like to leave the nuts out, or change them to pecans or brazil nuts…go for it. Not much for jelly? How about some dark chocolate chips nestled in that cute little indentation? We like to do a variety of jams in different colors for a festive look.
INGREDIENTS: I have used Earth Balance Soy Free Cubes in this (which incidentally is NOT the same as the spread which has more oil to make it spreadable and would change the texture big time in these). While this is not my preferred fat…with a son who thus far cannot even tolerate casein free grass-fed ghee, this is the fat I need to use to achieve the buttery flavor traditional to thumbprints. If you would like to use solid coconut oil or palm shortening, or can tolerate butter or ghee, those can be used here. The flavor will not be traditional with coconut oil or palm shortening, but they will still be tasty.
FILLING TIP: Have any leftover cranberry sauce? Makes a yummy filling!
Here are some more holiday cookies you could try!
- 1 cup Earth Balance Soy Free Butter Cubes, or any allowed butter, palm shortening, or coconut oil
- ½ cup palm sugar (or brown sugar)
- ¼ cup applesauce, unsweetened
- ⅛ teaspoon stevia powder or liquid stevia (could use an additional ¼ cup granulated sugar, or leave out entirely)
- 2 teaspoons vanilla extract
- ½ teaspoon sea salt
- 1 cup brown rice flour
- ½ cup EACH tapioca, sweet rice flour, and millet flour
- ½ teaspoon guar gum
- Preheat your oven to 350 degrees.
- In a mixing bowl, beat the the butter and sugar for about 2 minutes until fluffy.
- Turn the mixer down to low, and add in the applesauce, stevia, and vanilla. Beat well, mixture will appear almost curdled from the applesauce, that is OK.
- With mixer still running on low, sprinkle in the remaining dry ingredients one at a time. Hold off on the jelly and nuts at this point! Dough will be stiff.
- Grab about a tablespoon of dough and roll into balls.
- If you are using nuts, now is the time to roll the balls into the finely chopped walnuts.
- Place on a cookie sheet and press your thumb in the center to make an indentation for fillings.
- Use about a ½ teaspoon-1 teaspoon of jam per cookie. No exact science here, just fill your holes up...but don't overfill...the jam will spill out while it bakes and it does not look as pretty.
- Bake for about 10 minutes. Cookies should still be soft, but firm up perfectly as they cool.
Any of the links in my posts may be affiliate links. If you click on them and make a purchase, I might make a commission. Your support is much appreciated and pays for the cost of running this free resource!